Home
Deb Geisler
debgeisler
..:::. ..:.:.

November 2009
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30

Deb Geisler [userpic]
That word...I do not think it means what you think it does...

Mike and I were having pizza tonight, and he was telling me about a rather idiotic column he'd read on the train. Boston's Metro ran it today, and the piece mentions the wedding last week of Jenna Bush, one of the presidential daughters.

The author of the piece, Courtney Martin, lectures us about the forgotten meaning of weddings, and how horrific it is to spend huge amounts of time and money on them, and cautions that people need to think about the real purpose of weddings (as beginning marriages) and yadda yadda.

So, sure, there was a presidential wedding. And overall, it was a pretty low-key affair, given that it was the wedding of a daughter of the chief of state of a major world power (and one from a wealthy family).

But in her opening paragraph, Martin notes,

After Jenna Bush tied the knot last weekend at the family ranch in Crawford, Texas, our big daddy decider and hers told reporters: 'Our little girl Jenna married a really good guy, Henry Hager. The wedding was spectacular, all we could have hoped for.' His comment, besides misogynist (she's a 'little girl' while her new husband gets to be a bona fide guy) as usual...
"Our little girl/boy has grown up," the parents say. When a father refers to his daughter at her wedding as "our little girl," he's often being nostalgic and loving.

While I have my own problems with the current holder of the Oval Office, let us not be any more fatuous than is strictly necessary. It might help to look up (1) what misogynist means, and (2) note that it is a noun. [Yes, that was a grammar snipe.] I just don't see how a father's fond paternalism can be construed as a hatred of women.

Comments

Bush derangement syndrome. The right didn't make it up out of whole cloth, it really exists.

It's an important part of hate - turning the person into an object by finding fault with everything they do, making it wrong, wrong, wrong. As well as inhuman. You see this in every war.

(Anonymous)

American Heritage Dictionary, 4th Edition has it as a noun and an adjective.

And it is the only one of seven dictionaries whose definitions get rounded up on dictionary.com to do so. The rest understand that it is not necessary to include something just because a whole lot of ignorant people think it's correct.

(Anonymous)

Or if you bother looking through them, 2 out of 5. 1 is an encyclopedia and the other listing is an antonym. A dictionary is a dictionary, no? When was yours published?

Let's see...oh! 2008. And I understand how to sign my comments, too.

(Anonymous)

what does it matter if I make a fake name to write under? You see my IP, isn't that enough. Call me trimtab.

Why so defensive? So what, the word has evolved. That's how language works, I figured you would know that, being a dictionary author and all. By the way, what is the dictionary you're editing? I tried to find it on amazon, could only find something about space dolphins from the future. This is an English dictionary, right? Not Klingon?

Run along, little troll. You don't sign your posts, you don't get to play in my sandbox.

the troll defense is so cowardly..... so what if he does not sign his name? What do you want his address, phone number? Why not address the fact that he has two dictionaries that say you are wrong?

The little troll has one dictionary, online, that notes use as an adjective. We can certainly weigh dictionaries for days, but I view The Oxford English Dictionary and Merriam-Webster as definitive.

The "American Heritage" dictionary offers alternatives as they are used (and mis-used) in the vernacular.

As for the troll issue -- if someone is unwilling to sign their posts, my assumption is that they have a great reason for not wanting us to know who they are. And this is my sandbox -- it is social space, and people who play here want to know who we are talking to.

As they say... :)

Yeah, well. Sometimes, you figure that someone has just forgotten to sign a post or forgotten to log in.